Artvoice: Buffalo's #1 Newsweekly
Home Blogs Web Features Calendar Listings Artvoice TV Real Estate Classifieds Contact
Previous story: Cohen's Chain Connections
Next story: The Scottish Terror: Culloden

Visine Alert

Attention, film fans: The gods of cinema distribution want you to know that they are really, really sorry about last week, when the multiplexes were bombarded with Larry the Cable Guy and Stay Alive. In their defense they did give you Inside Man. Still, they recognize that Larry demands a lot of apologizing, so they’re making it up to you this week with more worthwhile movies than you can shake a stick at.

Vin Diesel in "Find Me Guilty"

Most of these films are playing at non-multiplex venues (including Culloden and Chain, reviewed separately in this issue). And even the best mainstream offering of the week has a quasi-indie aspect: Though it was directed by one of Hollywood’s finest, Sidney Lumet, and stars action hero Vin Diesel, Find Me Guilty is being handled by a small distributor and will be showing only at two suburban theaters. (A lot of smaller cities aren’t getting to see it at all.)

It’s worth the trip to the ’burbs. Lumet may be past 80, but this film, his first since 1999, bears comparison to some of his best, including 12 Angry Men, Serpico, Dog Day Afternoon and Prince of the City. Find Me Guilty is based on the federal criminal trial of New Jersey’s Lucchese crime family, an enormous undertaking that lasted a record 21 months in 1986-87. The government had spent years preparing it and was determined to convict all of the 20 defendants.

The film’s point of view is that of Giacomo “Jackie Dee” DiNorscio, a mid-level wiseguy already in prison at the start of the trial. Disgusted by what he sees as the uselessness of lawyers who want him to accept a plea deal to rat out his lifelong friends, Jackie decides to defend himself. A high school dropout with an ingratiating sense of humor, he figures he can sway the jury without too much trouble. But there are plenty of pitfalls he hasn’t foreseen, including the prosecutor’s ability to make his prison life difficult, the judge’s impatience with his disruptive antics and his co-defendents, who are afraid he’ll undo the strategies of their high-priced lawyers.

I’ve always had a special fondness for courtroom movies, and this one gets at all the elements that make the genre so intriguing: the artificiality of the behavior, the search for truth in such a constricted environment, the essential dignity of people submitting to such a system as a tool for something so ephemeral as justice.

Yes, I hear you saying, “…but…Vin Diesel?” Okay, I’ll admit that he may not be the next Olivier, and there are times when you can see Lumet working with him to get past some taxing moments. But he’s perfectly cast (having put on weight and hair for the part) and provides exactly what the role calls for: a scary guy who knows when to turn it on and off, with a naivete that is as touching as it is unlikely.

Like many mob stories, Find Me Guilty has one nagging fault: it fails to give us an excuse to root for the bad guys. Fans of the genre will know in advance how the trial ended and, given the shape of the story, it’s inevitable that we’ll root for Jackie. But it wasn’t inevitable that the prosecuting attorney be played (by Linus Roache) as such a dislikeable power freak. Even when he explodes in anger over exactly this issue, that the jury is refusing to recognize what evil scum the defendants are, the effect of the scene is to make us dislike him. Lumet seems to be encouraging this rather than using it for ironic effect; as a director who has so often told stories about criminals, his defense of the issue would be interesting to hear.

Robin Wright Penn in "Sorry, Haters"

Liking the bad guys is a whole different issue in Sorry, Haters, a film that had many viewers at last year’s Toronto Film Festival frothing at the mouth. It will be playing for one day only next Wednesday at the Emerging Cinema screen at the Market Arcade, and if you enjoy a lively discussion, by all means take a few friends to see it.

If that sounds like a backhanded compliment, so be it. Described by director Jeff Stanzler (Jumpin’ at the Boneyard) as “a psychological thriller with political and social undertones set in today’s New York City,” Sorry, Haters involves two characters, a professional woman who calls herself Philly (Robin Penn Wright) and a Muslim cabdriver named Ashade (Tunisian actor-director Abdellatif Kechiche). An émigré from Syria, where he held a Ph.D. in chemistry, Ashade is desperately trying to save his brother, who has been sent to Guantanamo on trumped-up charges and faces deportation back to Syria, where he will probably be tortured and executed. Learning of this, Philly offers to use her connections to help, an offer Ashade gratefully accepts, despite some rather peculiar behavior on her part.

That’s as much as I can say about a film which kept me guessing from beginning to end. Working in low-budget digital video on a short schedule gave Stanzler the ability to shoot a story that no studio would ever have financed; according to Roger Ebert, even Stanzler’s producers tried to get him to alter the film. The movie shocked me, perhaps gratuitously, perhaps not, I haven’t decided. Make up your own mind, and if nothing else be grateful for the chance to see something so risky.

Keith "Wild Child" Middleton in "Threat"

Threat, which plays on Friday, Saturday and Tuesday at the Screening Room in Amherst, has been widely anticipated by a reported 25,000 people who have been following its progress on the Internet. When NYU dropouts Katie Nisa and Matt Pizzolo decided to make a film about the nihilism of their generation, they dealt with a lack of resources and experience by turning to the net for help and advice. Their project helped them develop a crew of 200 volunteers who worked on the film, none of them older than Pizzolo (who was barely 22 when filming began).

It’s terrific that this collective, dubbed Kings Mob, had the patience and the drive to conceive of this film and to get it made under difficult circumstances. (As a side project Nisa and Pizzolo run a traveling DIY workshop at music festivals to help others get started on filmmaking.) And Threat shows a cinematic vision, even if its reach sometimes exceeds its grasp—forgivable for filmmakers who are learning on the job. It’s just a pity that the result is dramatically so murky. Reminiscent of both Spike Lee’s Do the Right Thing and Mike Leigh’s Naked, Threat wants to present a vision of urban youth as pitted against their own best interests, but there are too many poorly developed characters who do little but yak in the most generic terms about how everything sucks. The climactic street riot—which, as I learned only from reading the synopsis afterward, is supposed to pit hip-hop kids against straightedge punks—seems arbitrary, unconnected to anything we’ve previously seen.

Also at the Screening Room this weekend is Independent America: The Two-Lane Search for Mom & Pop, a documentary record of journalists Hanson Hoseinn and Heather Hughes’ 13,000-mile trip around 32 states in search of communities fighting to maintain local character in the face of big-box development. Which of course means that this is an anti-Wal-Mart film. Still, unlike the relentless hammering of statistics and damning evidence of many films in this post-Michael Moore genre, Independent America spends more time demonstrating the good effects of local business than it does damning those evil corporations. It doesn’t so much make you want to picket WalMart and Borders and Blockbuster as it does make you want to visit the Lexington Co-op and Talking Leaves and, oh gee, any independent video store that strikes your fancy.

Lovers of documentaries are in for a special treat beginning next Thursday when Emerging Cinema in conjunction with the New York Times presents selections from the Full Frame documentary festival for four nights. Opening night includes El Inmigrante (The Immigrant), unavailable for preview but described by the filmmakers as an examination of “the Mexican and American border crisis by telling the story of Eusebio de Haro, a young Mexican migrant who was shot and killed during one of his journeys north. The film presents a distinct humanitarian focus in which story and character take precedent over policy and empiricism.”

Madina Ali Yunye in "Rain in a Dry Land"

Also showing on Thursday is Rain in a Dry Land, an engrossing story of two Somali Bantu families in the first 18 months after they are relocated to the US. The film starts six months before their emigration, as we see them in the Kenyan refugee camp where they have been living for a dozen years after fleeing the Somalian civil war, in which all lost family members. The promise of life in a land of milk and honey fades as both they and their hosts struggle to acclimatize them to a wholly new way of life. As directed by Anne Makepeace and photographed by Joan Churchill, one of the camera operators on the seminal 1970s reality show “An American Family,” Rain in a Dry Land avoids sentimental clichés to show both the pitfalls and promises of dealing with a painful reality in too many parts of the world. The film will be repeated on Saturday, April 6 at 1:30pm; the Thursday screening will be followed by a Q&A with Anne Ireland, a former case worker with Journey’s End Refugee Services who has worked on Somali Bantu resettlement issues, and in Kenya as a Peace Corps volunteer.

Of course, all of these films combined probably won’t do as much business as one multiplex house showing Basic Instinct 2, which also opens Friday. To be honest, I went to the screening hoping for a ridiculous howler. Instead, I have to report that it’s not all that bad, at least after a preposterous opening scene with Sharon Stone as risk-addicted novelist Catherine Trammell seducing a stoned soccer star while driving 110 miles an hour through the streets of London. (It’s the first of a dozen or so Kids, Don’t Try This at Home Moments.) I would recommend it most of all to people who like to shop Toronto’s Yorkville neighborhood for their all-black wardrobes, though those looking for a cheap thrill might want to wait for the DVD: The slap-and-tickle stuff looks truncated enough to suggest that a theatrical release is only being done to grease the way (sorry for that image) for a much more lucrative home video release.