Artvoice: Buffalo's #1 Newsweekly
Home Blogs Web Features Calendar Listings Artvoice TV Real Estate Classifieds Contact
Previous story: Common Council report
Next story: Delano takes the stand

Opening up on Syaed Ali

Buffalo Police say state and federal agencies are in on the case; state and federal agencies deny it

First the Syaed Ali case, now the Brian Davis investigation: Up until last week, Buffalo Police Department spokesperson Mike DeGeorge insisted that it was against BPD policy to comment on ongoing investigations. Now he can’t seem to stop himself from commenting on ongoing investigations.

DeGeorge started rewriting the rules last week, sharing information about the investigation of Syaed Ali with the Buffalo News and Channel 7 Eyewitness News.

Ali is the young IT entrepreneur accused of sending anonymous emails containing allegations about Mayor Byron Brown’s private life. On November 7, armed with a search warrant signed by Buffalo City Court Judge Craig Hannah, Buffalo Police detectives searched Ali’s house on Breckenridge, confiscated his and his family’s possessions, and whisked Ali downtown to the local office of the New York State Attorney General, where he was held for seven hours without ever being arrested or read his rights. Ali says he was told that if he contacted a lawyer or family member he would be arrested and charged with aggravated harassment. He claims that his interrogators asked him to admit he had sent the anonymous emails under direction from the mayor’s political rivals, including New York State Assemblyman Sam Hoyt and South District Councilmember Mickey Kearns.

When he was finally released, Ali says he was told that if he spoke to the media or a lawyer about what had happened to him that morning, he would be arrested and charged.

Ali hired the firm of Magavern Magavern & Grimm the next business day. Three months later, he still has not been charged with any crime and police are still holding his possessions. Now Ali has spoken to the news media, too—and, like DeGeorge, can’t seem to stop talking—and Buffalo Police have come forth to suggest he’ll be charged.

Two weeks ago DeGeorge told Artvoice he would not comment on the investigation at all—would not even confirm that there was an investigation. Last week he told Channel 7 and the Buffalo News that police were investigating Ali, prompted by concerns expressed by the mayor’s bodyguards that the emails posed a substantial threat to the mayor and his family.

DeGeorge added that, while currently Ali faced possible charges of aggravated harassment and criminal impersonation, Buffalo Police had reached out to federal and state law enforcement agencies, and it was possible that new, more serious charges would be added to those.

That seems unlikely, based on recent conversations with state and federal law enforcement agencies.

Earl Gould of the FBI’s Buffalo office said that as a rule the agency does not comment on its ongoing investigations. Then he added, “From our standpoint, if we ran out and talked to the guy, that’s all we did—we talked to him and we pretty much decided there was no federal violation.”

FBI agents often check out leads brought to their attention by local law enforcement, he said. But if there’s no federal crime, they drop it. “Regardless of what you see in the movies, we pretty much bow out if it’s not us,” he said. “You can’t make a silk purse of a sow’s ear. It is what it is.”

That doesn’t mean the FBI would no re-engage the case if a federal angle were to assert itself, Gould cautioned. But he said that hasn’t happened yet with the Ali case.

Rich Bamberger, a spokesperson for the New York State Attorney General’s office, told me several times in the course of a conversation last week, “It’s not our case. This is all Buffalo Police.”

To hear what Syaed Ali has to say about all this, visit AV Daily at Artvoice.com, where you’ll find a video interview with Ali.

geoff kelly

blog comments powered by Disqus